Marley and Me/Tale of Desperaux

Hey 4A! Have you seen either/both of the new Marley and Me or Tale of Desperaux movies? Have you read the books? Did you enjoy the movie better than the book, or the book better than the movie? Would you recommend the books to a friend even if you haven't seen the movie? Now's your chance to post your own response to this book. Tell the members of 4A what you think..... Remember, don't give away the ending of the books or movie for those who haven't seen the movies or read the books yet!